This
article on 3 pages in the times is a riveting read for those interested in comedy, movies, politics and whisky. Here’s a quick extract, but do read the full version. I love it when papers like this come out from the 1940s. It surely Was a pivotal time for Britain and the world.
‘In his book Highlanders: A History of the Gaels, John Macleod (no relation to the
lifeboatman) raises questions about the destination of the SS Politician and her
cargo, hinting at some kind of conspiracy.
“The episode was a great embarrassment to the government,” he writes, “and to this
day certain papers on the Politician affair remain classified. It has been suggested
that the assorted goodies were for a very important person — an American statesman
whose support was vital in Washington or President Roosevelt himself; even the Duke
of Windsor has been named as a recipient.”
It makes a good conspiracy theory. But the simpler possibility is that the Politician’s
cargo was intended to bring in much-needed money from America. That would, directly
or indirectly, have gone towards fighting Hitler. And, in the unlikely case that
Roosevelt did need to be bribed, a few thousand bottles of whisky might seem a fair
exchange for American entry into the war.
Hardly surprisingly, Mackenzie skates over any consequences of the islanders’ actions.
Whisky Galore is, after all, a comedy and in 1947 many people simply wanted to forget…’